I’m studying for my Law class and don’t understand how to answer this. Can you help me study?
Case Scenario Review:
The defendant, charged with murder, asks his wife to tell the police he arrived home on the night of the murder @ 7:30 p.m., about an hour before the victim was killed. Initially, the wife did as requested. However, she subsequently changed her mind and told police her husband came home @ 9:05. At the husband’s trial for the murder, the prosecution wishes to have the wife testify that her husband “Asked me to lie to give a false alibi.”
I. Summarize the facts of the case.
II. Respond to the questions below:
*Q: Is her testimony admissible?
Consider these variables:
- A. Your state has a “testimonial privilege” that permits a spouse to prevent the other spouse from testifying, but the husband and wife are divorced before the murder trial begins.
- B. Your state has only a “marital communication” privilege. Is the statement by the husband to the wife (i.e., lie to the police about when he got home), a confidential communication? If so, does it survive the marriage? (See